All episodes · Episode 5 · · 1h 28m
Ethereum Since 2017, ConsenSys & MetaMask, Growing ENS into Registry for Everything
with jamesbeck.eth
Listen on
About this episode
James Beck has been in Ethereum since 2017: ConsenSys, MetaMask, Mirror, and now ENS Labs. But before crypto, he was leading American journalists on trips to China.
We talk about how a book on Ethereum changed his path, what ConsenSys looked like with 49 incubated projects, why the cypherpunk vs. institutional divide never went away, the end of the easy money era, Mirror’s sale to Paragraph, why agentic commerce is still just devs playing around, and the plan to make ENS the naming standard for tokenized stocks, companies, and AI agents.
Takeaways
- James went from leading US journalist trips to China to crypto via one book on Ethereum
- “Non nation state money” was the realization that pulled him in
- ConsenSys in 2017: 49 incubated projects, daily hires, constant Slack wars
- Of all the ConsenSys spokes, only MetaMask survived
- The divide between institutional blockchain and cypherpunks still shapes Ethereum today
- Banks went from treating Ethereum as a toy at Sibos 2018 to demoing their own EVM ledgers in 2026
- Ethereum’s neutrality is exactly why TradFi keeps choosing it
- Every wallet is trying to become the everything app
- The easy money and airdrop era was a zero interest rate phenomenon, and retail is not coming back
- FTX damaged crypto’s reputation more than any crash, then Trump coin made it worse
- Sustainable revenue, not VC subsidies, now decides which crypto companies survive
- Mirror’s dollar per mint model could not sustain a business, so it was sold to Paragraph
- On chain music platforms had the community but not the economics
- Agentic commerce is still devs testing: Tempo has around 6,000 active addresses and $14 in daily fees
- Nobody needs an agent to buy a sandwich
- Alternate namespaces recreate the name collision problem that standards exist to solve
- ENS is becoming a registry layer: company LEIs, tokenized stocks, agent identity
- ENS Labs wants one shared RWA registry standard instead of one per issuer
- Address poisoning scams are ironically the strongest sales argument for ENS
- Next for ENS: buying names with no wallet and no crypto, plus a wave of new ENSIPs
Chapters 19
Transcript auto-generated
Auto-generated by Riverside, lightly imperfect. Download as text .
Kris but man, thank you for Turk, thank you for joining. Let's let's let's kick it off like that. for those who don't know, this is James Beck, my next guest. And James, you're the OG Ethereum since to since 2017. You worked at ConsenSys, MetaMask, Mirror, which is the platform that I used like very, very dearly. I wanna talk about to you to talk to talk about All of these things. you're also a music producer. I told you I had my agents look you up, bruh. So you're a music producer.
jamesbeck.eth Uh-huh. Nice.
Kris You you make music, that's awesome. I want to talk about that. I just had Nick from UFO on the podcast as well.
jamesbeck.eth great, Nick Collins. Yeah.
Kris we shared some stories. but yeah, man. let's explore this Ethereum journey of yours. But let's actually do your do you mind if we like take it way back? I I'm I'm interested I'm interested in in your background. I think you started political science. how about how about we start there?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, I sure. so I just even start before that, I looked up what Mirac means in Serbian and it is
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth it correct to say it's like spontaneity and sort of like another word might be kismet
Kris It's
jamesbeck.eth or s yeah, when things and ideas come together spontaneously.
Kris so I think it has a few meanings. The most original one was probably like the Turkish from the Turkish origins,
jamesbeck.eth Okay.
Kris where it meant like some kind of a curiosity, chasing something that that you know
jamesbeck.eth Mm.
Kris to kind of satisfy your curiosity. But since then, since Serbia like historically has been under Turkish occupation for like five hundred years, we've taken that and you know how words usually sometimes evolve. And now it came to mean that like extracting the most amount of pleasure from the enjoy from simplest of things. It kind of goes against
jamesbeck.eth that's a different meaning.
Kris it's kind of goes against this kind of trend of like consumerism and like I need to get this, I
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris need to get that. No, you just wake up and you just enjoy your coffee, enjoy a conversation and just like do
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris things out of the sheer pleasure. So yeah.
jamesbeck.eth That's that's beautiful. That's a that's a a life a lifestyle to keep reminding yourself of and try to live. It's easy to get out of that. And some people say anxiety is fear of the future, depression is focusing too much on the past. But if you're very present, you're hopefully getting the miracle life, you know, just enjoying that sip of coffee.
Kris Yeah, exactly. It's that blissful state.
jamesbeck.eth my so I thought the spontaneity and the curiosity meaning in Turkish. was interesting as a tie-in to going back to, my college era and I went to a liberal arts college, which in the United States they're a little bit separate from unis, in which they actually require that you get a multidisciplinary education. So you have to learn hard sciences like physics and mathematics, but you also have to take a humanities course or a number of humanities courses, history courses, et cetera. And I think just how my parents raised me. They've, I grew up with a lot of books and always encouraged us to read everything and anything and learn about everything. so while in college, I really bounced around. I thought I was gonna be a biology major. And then I had a few
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth friends that were studying Chinese. And I was just so impressed, you know, going to the library and seeing them write Chinese characters. And like I realized maybe my, you know. Poor Spanish, I wouldn't be doing so poorly if I actually challenged myself and learned something that is so different in terms of the writing system. So I started studying
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth Chinese and studied at Tsinghua University in Beijing, and also had an interest in political philosophy. And so I combined those and was like a political philosophy major, Chinese minor, and really thought that after graduating, I I moved to China and got a job helping Chinese students apply to top universities in the US.
Kris Hmm.
jamesbeck.eth And thought I would kind of just be permanently what's called th there's this term in Chinese which is called a China hand, meaning a foreigner who spends a great deal of time, knows the language, and understands Chinese culture enough to be a a helpful translator to the rest of the world or their home country. And, you know, we can talk about the whole Jensen Huang thing. yeah.
Kris I was gonna say, is this a taboo topic to talk about this now? Talking about how you had I think you
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris were working with like some what did you what did you do? I'm I'm kinda curious to your take. I don't wanna
jamesbeck.eth So starting in twenty fourteen, while I was living in China, Facebook was still only accessible via VPN. And, you know, people still used it. And I found that was like the best way to keep in touch with people. And all of a sudden, in my feed, I started seeing these translated policy articles from, you know, the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences or Beijing University professors. And I was like, this is fascinating. It read like a foreign policy or Financial Times, you know, there'd be like thousand-word articles saying this is China's position on Tibet, or this is what China thinks about Barack Obama, or, you know, here's what they fear about a Hillary Clinton presidency in 2016, or what they think about Trump. And I was like, you never get these perspectives. Who's behind this? And so I ended
Kris Hm.
jamesbeck.eth up finding an email address and reaching out to them cold saying. Hi, I'm curious about what you do and who's behind this organization called the China United States Exchange Foundation. Didn't get any responses, and three months later I got an email saying, Hey, I'm I'm in Hong Kong, let's meet up. And it was someone who's from the US. And I said, I'm really curious about your organization and who you work with, and would love to, you know, I'm planning on moving back to New York. I'd love to consider, you know, I want to apply to work there. And What I ended up finding out is that the Chinese Exchange Foundation was started by the first president of Hong Kong when it was returned from the British back to China. so if if you, remember British imperialism, they sort of leased what we now call Hong Kong from mainland China for a ninety-nine year period of time. And then in nineteen ninety-seven, that's when that old document was set to expire. And so for the first time ever.
Kris Okay.
jamesbeck.eth There was this big event and China was gonna get Hong Kong back, except there were some rules around it. They were saying it's gonna be a a special administrative region, meaning they could elect their own leaders. You know, it's still part of China and turn and China thinks of everything in like 2000 to 5000 year history. They're like, This has always been a part of China. But people growing up in Hong Kong thought of it, especially post 1997, as okay, we're this sort of new independent region. And so their first president they elected was someone who just passed away last month. He's his name was Tung Chee-hwa. And he spent a he was the son of a billionaire shipping magnet. So, like, you know, import-export was huge, and they were the company that like put the big shipping containers on ships. And so he was this wealthy billionaire who spent a lot of time in Europe and the United States, and then When he retired from political office, he realized that the the relationship between the US and China was always strained because the people from the US don't spend enough time in China and vice versa. And so he started a foundation. And the the goal of the foundation was to spend money to get American influencers. Back then the term was like policy leaders, but really like to bring American students at top universities to bring re elected representatives in the US, senators and representatives, and then journalists on sort of like a 10 day trip to learn about the real China. And so my job was to both be an editor for the magazine which published Chinese foreign policy views and to take journalists basically like fine journalists that would agree to go on these 10 day trips to China to learn.
Kris So h how old were you at the time?
jamesbeck.eth back then I would have been twenty five and very young.
Kris Do you mind me asking how old are you now? okay, okay. I thought you I th I thought like you were speaking to some like events. I'm 33, but you were speaking
jamesbeck.eth I'm I just turned thirty seven on Friday. Yeah. how old are you, Cap? Yeah. Yeah.
Kris about these 1997 events as if you were there and witnessed it. I was like,
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris okay, am I dealing with like I was I was expecting sixty-five
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. I'm a young sixty-five. Well, the the reason why it f it's recent, it's because it it's like Hong Kong has only been quote unquote independent for twenty years.
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth because it was under British imperial rule before that for ninety-nine years and then part of broader China. But the other thing was it was helpful to tell journalists that because they were like, well, typically under our rules of engagement, we don't take Free trips from anyone because they know it's just gonna be a propaganda tour. And that was a challenge. I I essentially was leading propaganda tours on behalf of the Chinese government, knowing that
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth journalists were gonna be very skeptical. And and then the the way that the US viewed China was also changing. So when Xi Jinping became president in 2015, they all of a sudden were very strict about Americans that were trying to interact with people in China. so what I ended up realizing is that there was kind of this defensive feeling I had when I would read mainstream news in Anglo artic articles about China being like, we must contain China. China's rise is
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth smoke and mirrors, they're gonna have a financial crash, they just copy US technology, like all of the negative stuff you read about China. And then you'd go there and the average Beijing taxi driver would be like, where are you they'd say this in Chinese, where are you from? And you'd say the
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth United States, and they'd be like, yeah, America, so strong, love America. And
Kris Yeah. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth they didn't really have a negative view of the United States. so all all of this to say, I'll I'll kind of speed it up, but I was doing this kind of like they called it like track two dialogues, and we'd meet with really important people. We'd meet with like, you know, head of the People's Liberation Army generals, we'd meet with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. we never met with Xi Jinping, but we had bilateral meetings with the various people in government departments that that essentially
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth were making policy around how the US should act and how the how China should act. And my job was very much like a facilitator of this. I wasn't allowed to really ask questions during meetings. I was just a handler. And all of a sudden I started getting really nervous about. what I was doing. I had to sign the Foreign Agents Registration Act in the United States, which labeled me as a potential foreign agent. I wasn't able to get a clearance to do global entry for a long time. So I started becoming aware that I was on both lists in China and lists in the United States. And that was affecting other parts of my life and generally it was making me quite anxious. And one
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth and one time I was taking a group of journalists, and one was from Bloomberg, and Ethereum had just launched, and there were all of a sudden the ICO boom, Golem had done a record ICO, and there were a number of ICOs taking place in mainland China, and then all of a sudden, within a month, they were banned. and Bitcoin was banned again, and Ethereum was banned again from the exchanges. And he said he was like reporting on cryptocurrency occasionally, and he's like, Do you know anything about ICOs? And I was like, I've never heard of it. I didn't really have a financial background. So I was like, it sounds like an IPO.
Kris Is that how you got into crypto?
jamesbeck.eth So he asked me, and then at the same time, one of my friends, I well, n I had bought Bitcoin before, but it was for other reasons. It was like, it was not as an investment, it was like f
Kris Well o yeah.
jamesbeck.eth for using Tor bra like it was for the dark web. And
Kris Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth but I never thought of it as an investment or anything beyond like, this is that weird internet money you use if you want to do stuff. On tour browsing. But then my friend was like, you know, should actually read this book. And he gave me a book called Ethereum. And it was written by an IBM researcher, Henning Diedrich. It was an amazing sort of like intro to what Ethereum is as a smart contract platform, focused on potential use cases, a lot of around like law and legal agreements, and saying, well, a smart contract collapses execution in agreement. Me and that to me blew my mind. I was like, collapses execution agreement. Okay, so that means in s if like two parties agree on something, actually it's just automatically enforced at a contract level by the world computer of Ethereum. And
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth so I was I was reading this book on the flight, finished it while I was on that trip, and when I came back, blockchain mania had taken over. Fortune magazine had a whole article about blockchain and all the potential use cases. And a lot of the interviews were with folks at ConsenSys, which was located in Brooklyn at the time. And I realized then and there, I need to get into this. I I feel like I'm at the the very first front door of this like very big sort of society societally transforming technology. And I I just really it was like I
Kris Do you remember do you remember what was it? Like what w what would what do you attribute the kind of the turning point in your career to that? Like is it reading that book? Was it something from that book? Do you remember? Or is it a person that to you know, told you about something that was kind of you know, like the light bulb light bulb moment?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, I think y you look at what was happening in China, and China was all of a sudden ever they're having their own digital transformation. It was like everyone was using WeChat, mobile payments were starting up. It was still early enough that most people used cash, but I started realizing like if you want the ultimate surveillance machine, no better tool than the internet. You know, China already had its great firewall. And I felt for the first time there was like almost this new technology that could circumvent that. That could bring the internet back to its original ideas. Almost in like in the John Perry Barlow Electronic Frontier Foundation sense of we need to have it's like countries are these imagined nation states, you know, tied together by technology or by language and history. But generally the internet flattened all of that. But it by 2015 it felt like big tech was like reinforcing those differences and When I read about cryptocurrency and specifically Ethereum, I felt this is the first time where beyond just information, we have a potential to make money that is non nation state dependent. And that was, to me, the most profound realization of reading this book. I was like, what about non nation state money? How powerful could that be? and consensus was consensus
Kris Non nation state money. Sounds really cool.
jamesbeck.eth was like very much on that wave. You know, Joe Lubin talked about, you know, he was kind of like, A libertarian, but at the same time really was a believer in the early power of the internet to connect people globally and thought of society as not being dependent on where you're from or your history or your background, but rather what value systems do you want to ascribe to. And and so yeah, I joined Consensus and at the time, I think I was like employee number four hundred something. It was a mess, man. It was like every day ten to fifteen more people were hired. You'd talk to someone and you'd say, What do you work on? And they'd be like, I started a new spoke. Spoke was the term for a company. And you'd be like, Okay, what does this spoke do? And they're like, We're gonna transform insurance and do insurance on the blockchain. Or someone's like, We're gonna do real estate on Ethereum.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth So So and then MetaMask was We're building a wallet so you can access Ethere Ethereum. But they had very little support from the rest of the consensus org because really it was just anything goes. You know, we're We're gonna build central bank digital currencies. We're gonna work with JP Morgan. there was no real vision for what this would. And I think Joe knew that and he was okay with that. He just said, Let's get all these smart people caring about Ethereum and then they'll do something that hopefully supports the network. So yeah, I that was my journey to crypto.
Kris So what was your position at consensus? What did you do? Because I know
jamesbeck.eth I
Kris I'm just curious, what is the the first position that you've held since you've worked with you know w what would I even call that position that you've just explained with ch with China and r with policy relations or
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. It was Paul yeah, international public relations and and I
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth leveraged that to get at my first job at ConsenSys, which was all of a sudden the New York Times and Financial Times and Deutsche Well were writing to Consensus saying, Hey, we're reading about Ethereum. Can Joe Lubin do an interview? the New Yorker was gonna do a profile on they did a profile on him. So they needed someone to be a public relations person, and I was I can do that. And I got hired alongside
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth someone named Caramiley, who we got hired on the the same day. And so I then leveraged that into other things, which,
Kris Can you I'm very curious, this is this is gold by the way. So you joined two thousand and seventeen. I joined crypto by the way two thousand and eighteen. I s I I was mining Bitcoin for just fun when I was a student and that was two thousand
jamesbeck.eth cool.
Kris and thirteen. but then I I went all in in two thousand and eighteen after just a series of misfortunate events and breakups and health and all of those things. And I was just fuck it, let's put it all on black or on red. and for me that was let's go all and Bitcoin and then Ethereum and then started learning about it w after I had put my money in it. So I had to learn the very hard way what bridging means, what different blockchains meant, what all of these things meant. Bridging wasn't even a term at the time. 2018, after the DeFi summer twenty nineteen, then we started kind of coining these new terms taxes and bridges and all these things. But I'm curious how does the ecosystem, how does the Ethereum ecosystem look in two thousand seventeen, right before probably the biggest boom that we even haven't surpassed yet in terms of at least price price action? you know, when it comes to these even majors Ave and and and others.
jamesbeck.eth Well, I think there was a real divide at consensus, culturally and in terms of what people wanted to do with the technology. So at around that,
Kris say more.
jamesbeck.eth well, there was you the Slack then was juicy. There's constant arguments, people calling each other psychopaths or sociopaths. It was very divisive time. And I think part of the reason was the let's just call them the the old money types. People who worked at Goldman Sachs or McKinsey Consulting, they saw it as a transformative tool for businesses. They're blockchains are going to transform businesses. But at the time, the only possibility was through private permissioned Ethereum networks. So you'd kind of take an EVM network
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth and you would allow the banks to roll back the chain if they needed to. And then there were the hardcore anarchist,
Kris Cypherpunks.
jamesbeck.eth decentralization, cypherpunk maxis who are you guys are getting it all wrong. We shouldn't be going to the World Economic Forum Davos. We should be going, we should be doubling down on what is now called crops with the EF. So that divide existed even then. And I think it really colored the way that consensus acted. We on the one hand, on the marketing team, we were highlighting here's 20 projects you can use on Ethereum today. And it would be it'd be largely gambling stuff. I remember using one DAP called Dice to Win. And it literally, you would connect your MetaMask wallet, you'd press a button and it would roll these die. And if you won, it was basically a a dice gambling game. And
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth you could get ETH back if you wanted. And and so someone was building a poker game on-chain. MetaMask existed. There was a lot of developer tools Truffle and Infura being built. and then on the other side, which was equally a focus of the company, we were talking to central banks and saying, what would it be to pilot, central bank digital currencies on a private permissioned Ethereum network? and then by DeFi summer, that schism really happened where a lot of companies that were doing more experimental stuff on mainnet Ethereum got spun out, and then the core business became financial whoa. Huge.
Kris Damn, again.
jamesbeck.eth I bring that up because I think that same divide is very present today. I was just at DevCon and in some ways some people were mourning the fact that DEV CON felt smaller or none of the big projects were there. Other people criticized it for saying there isn't any serious financial institutions that are at DEF CON. And I think the point of DEV CON is to really care about protocol improvements and the protocol health. And I really do agree with the whole focus on censorship resistant money, because actually that's the reason why. If you go to the institutions, they actually that more than what we're seeing with Canton and Tempo. Essentially, w in my opinion, no business is gonna want to basically have someone else can control the infra. you could create a consortium of banks and they can collectively own the infra, but then it's either you're in the consortium or you're not in the consortium. But what makes Ethereum so powerful and why it's still the chosen chain for a lot of these businesses and financial TradFi is because it still feels uncontrolled by it's the most decentralized smart contract platform. And that actually is the benefit of the internet. That's the benefit of Ethereum. So I think that divide is gonna always be present. we are gonna be in a world, I think, by 2030, 2035, where There are central bank digital currencies managed by countries. There might
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth be chains managed by a consortium of banks, but there should still be Ethereum, the neutral fallback layer that isn't control. It's literally just the network and the people running nodes.
Kris Yeah. So maybe a weird question, but which camp did you belong to? Were you more on the cypherpunkish, you know, profile of the user or were you more on the institutionals? Because I feel you you kind of can fit both camps, you know.
jamesbeck.eth Well, in my position in marketing I had to fit both camps. but when it came down to competing priorities, I often chose
Kris Personal choice.
jamesbeck.eth my personal choice was the cypherpunk camp. one example was I think it was DEF CON four in Prague, was the exact same time, around the same time as the Swift Interbank Operations Seminar, Cybos. And so The Trad5 folks went to Sibos, the Cypherpunks went to DEF CON, I went to DEF CON. yeah.
Kris Yeah. But you recently were at Cyfo Sibos, is that what you call? Yeah. Right.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. for the first time. Yeah. And so yeah, we have to kind of grow up and put on the suits a little bit. Not that you have to
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth negate the cypherpunk stuff, but I I actually found it fascinating how in twenty eighteen when Consensus was at Sibos, they thought of it as Hmm, what a cool toy, you know, it this Ethereum thing. this seems like it'll
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth be useful, but no one's gonna use it. To then Today, or this year at Sibos, every single bank all they wanted to talk about was their tokenization plans and you know, agent finance. It was literally, you know, Swift themselves, which run the interbank messaging system for cross-border payments, spent most of their time doing demos on their Beisu EVM built network. They're s they're calling it the Swift Ledger. So
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth huge change, not even eight years later that all the banks are realizing, okay, this technology is not good not not only is it not going away, it's
Kris Undeniable.
jamesbeck.eth undeniable. it's a massive improvement from what they're using today.
Kris Yeah. Man, when I'm talking to people in this kind of format, I'm usually fishing for some keywords, a trigger words that I can attach myself to so I can keep keep the conversation going. But with you, you just threw you just threw some bombs. Ethereum, like the
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris prog I'm s I have so many questions, does Ethereum need, you know, traditional institutions? Is it good? Is it bad?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris Agentic finance. Hell we can talk so much about that. We can talk about cybers.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, yeah.
Kris So you're throwing some some really big topics. for me to think about, which is what's your person what do you want to talk about?
jamesbeck.eth well, I'd be remiss to not mention V2 launched. That feels like a big relief. Okay.
Kris yeah, we'll get into that. We'll get into that. I wanna I wanna allocate a speci a a section to for this. One thing that let's take it a little back. One thing from from consensus that I that I was really it was fascinating for me to find out was that you guys actually incubated a lot of projects. including MetaMask and and you work with so many teams, you work with so many projects, so and you were kind of there, front and center, helping them doing PR, doing you have kind of this Bird's eye, storyteller's view, perspective on the whole thing, right? So in your opinion, I assume most of them died, but do are there any major ones outside of MetaMask that are still out there or still working?
jamesbeck.eth That's a great question. I I would say by twenty eighteen there were forty nine projects that Consensus was incubating. Today it's really just MetaMask. and
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth even I was kind of surprised when I read the news that Consensus itself rebranded to become MetaMask. So I I think part of it too was, you know, when was Uniswap created? Was it twenty nineteen? Or twenty twenty.
Kris probably some something that uni swap.
jamesbeck.eth I there was actually a company called AirSwap, which was doing RFC swapping, or RFQ, request for quote. That s that technology became what eventually became the swap feature in MetaMask. Infura was basically about Infura used to be very controversial. It was let's run nodes on AWS servers, and
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth you'd go to DevCon and people would be This is not decentralized, this is awful. And
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth Infura is now what powers the main if you're not using a different node provider, so it's kind of it used to be piecemeal. There's different companies that all became part of MetaMask because eventually we realized MetaMask was the front door to interacting with Ethereum. And then all these things we were building, DeFi projects and whatever, could just basically be features in the app itself.
Kris Yeah, I think they're and correct me if I'm wrong, but they are doubling down on Metamask becoming a a modern neo bank or like a financial institution for yeah. Yeah, everything.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. Savings, gambling, trading, everything.
Kris I hate that trend. Every every wallet on a for obvious reasons. Yeah,
jamesbeck.eth Every app every app wants to be the everything app.
Kris everyone is adding prediction markets and bets and perps
jamesbeck.eth I know.
Kris and everything, everything, everything. It's just I'm actually
jamesbeck.eth Too much.
Kris really contemplating creating of the most boring wallet. And I'm gonna
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris probably market it to recovering DJs myself. And I'm gonna be
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, yeah.
Kris just use this wallet to save money. And I like
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris I'm even I'm genuinely thinking about creating a wallet without send button. So you can receive money, but
jamesbeck.eth Wow.
Kris you cannot you cannot send money outside. You can do it still.
jamesbeck.eth a w a one way vault.
Kris Exactly. You can still do it, obviously. You can just export the private key and seed phrase and you
jamesbeck.eth Mm.
Kris know. Plug it into MetaMask or whatever else. And sand fans if you really want to. but I I I don't know. We'll see. Maybe.
jamesbeck.eth It's a savings account. So th well, I needed someone to d do that with my wallets because I ended up spending so much money over the years on tokens that have gone to zero or NFTs.
Kris Exactly.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris And you know what's what's funny? I I'm aware of my kind of this idiosyncrasy that I just spend money that I allocate to some wallet that is okay, this is gonna be my savings account. And then I go whatever, Ave is down whatever night percent, you know? And I'm this is a great buy. So I just buy for some ridiculous amounts of money. And then it goes down another 10-20%, and I get annoyed, so I have to wait, and then from there Whatever else new thing c new thing comes out and I'm I have to invest here, I have to invest. But anyway, so this is this my idea is to have a very curated set of assets, few tokenized assets, few, I don't know, stocks, ETFs, total of fifty. Nothing else.
jamesbeck.eth You could you could set up a multi sig so that you have to convince a friend to sign off on something to hold you accountable. So you're
Kris that's great idea. But that means that your friend will actually be kind of in charge of your money moving.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, they'd be one signer, yeah. It'd be a maybe a pair family member, someone you trust.
Kris Yeah. The the savings wallet destroying families since twenty twenty six. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth My I guess my question for you, Cap, it it used to be in when you were doing DeFi summer stuff, I I remember doing really s weird a lot of the farm DeFi farming for I'm even forgetting the names, I feel there's one Yam Finance and all these food related DeFi schemes.
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth All of those really paid to be an early tester and user and We would write a quarterly DeFi report and it I remember reading the first one not too long ago. It was tw it was twenty twenty and it was so shocking how little money was in DeFi and how every quarter we'd write a new report. We'd be the total number of stable coins is 10x since the last quarter, since the last one. And the whole point of this was to get people in the company and to have the broader people worrying about thinking about Ethereum. To just try out these protocols because it really paid to use them. Getting the Uniswap airdrop, getting an ENS name
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth led to the ENS airdrop. There's a lot of things where testing and trying something actually was really financially beneficial and it was really fun to use crypto. My question to you is have you found that there's been anything since that era that has been, you know, sort of paid off to be early?
Kris for me personally not really. I did use stuff. I did I did use a lot of stuff. I got some ridiculous airdrops to be honest. I missed ENS. I think I got very little allocation from Uniswap and but I did get a lot of airdrops. what was what was the one that I'm I'm kinda blanking on? I and I wish I saved all of this, but I didn't. I probably gambled them away on something. the biggest one that I've gotten was on Solana. It was some protocol. I had some Sol and I was whatever I have, 10K, it wasn't even that much. And it's just sitting in my wallet. Let me find some lowest risk protocol with some reasonable APY. And I just locked it, locked it there and I had it locked for a year. And they just airdrop me twenty k thirty K or something that of their token. And I'm sure, great, whatever. You know, at the time when everything is good and fluctuating and everything is at the top, you you think you're always gonna be doing good and you think things are gonna just keep looking better from from that point onwards. But boy was I wrong.
jamesbeck.eth the the best advice I ever I think I read online. I didn't receive it, but someone said, if you ever have the urge to show a friend or family member your crypto portfolio, that's the exact moment to sell.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth And that echoed in my head when this was in, I guess just two years ago, I was also playing around on Solana and I bought fartcoin and I had made a s A lot more money than I put in. And I felt the urge. I I showed my dad. I was yeah, man, crypto's ridiculous right now. Look at this fart coin. And he's and then I realized I was wait, I'm showing my dad my fart coin balance. I should sell this. And I did. I'm glad I did because it's been down since. But yeah, I think also if you're to look at the broader macroeconomic trends, some could argue that we'll never actually it's not about crypto returning to that. It's about That was part of a zero interest rate phenomena of having such low interest rates in the United States and globally for so long.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth maybe our twenties and thirties were early 30s were really that era of easy money. And so with easy money came lots of investment in projects. Projects were looking for users. They were just literally giving away money that their investors had given them. There's a lot of arguments to be said that, interest rates are not coming down for a long time and that. That era
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth of easy money is over for, our for maybe the next decade or two. it a lot has to
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth change in the economy for it to feel there's easy money floating around. And I also think people would say, well, what about the hype airdrop? Or, it was if you were early on perps trading, you would have gotten that big airdrop, or someone could say, No, there's still money to be made on pump.fun. And it's More money more people lose money from that than make money
Kris No.
jamesbeck.eth from it. It's and I think enough people have been burned that there's not really a retail ever coming back. I think it was kind of a momentary era. so kind of going back to what we're saying about crypto being boring and TradFi, I think a lot of that has to do with companies need to create sustainable revenue. We're not we're beyond the free money from VC's era and The way to create sustainable revenue is to have repeat customers and and have a business that i is sustainable. And I don't think the pet project interesting ideas cypherpunk stuff will ever go away. And I'm glad. I think there's enough people that truly care about creating, Anon wallet or Ambire wallet or even Kohaku, these new wallet plays that are coming out of the EF and are part of this crop stuff. There's always going to be a a s core group of people that care about that. and it's going to be open sourced and it's done in a way that even if the company shuts down, there should still be a way to access it. But that's not really it's just not financially sustainable. I think it's good that it exists and it should always exist, but it's not the way to build a company or a business around it.
Kris Yeah. Man, those were the days.
jamesbeck.eth Those were the days, yeah.
Kris those were the days, my friend. everything was so easy.
jamesbeck.eth We didn't know it then.
Kris I I had no clue. I remember, you know, when I was the most kind of shook? everything was new and everything is wild and every single day was something new. and the thing that kind of shook me shook you know kind of shook me to my very core was Terra Luna collapse. It's forty billion dollars wiped. away overnight. It literally disappeared. And I remembers you know at at the time I was kind of at the at the at the at the end of my DGN meme coining trading kind of career after making and losing so much money, man. So much money. and I and that then that happened and I remember just I was back there in my room and I was literally j for probably two weeks I was every every night I was just laying in bed, watching at the ceiling, doing nothing. I was so I think I don't even know how to describe that feeling. You know? It just there's nothing, emptiness. You know, it's it's it's it kind of so it's not a depression, it's not I don't know what it was, but but it was
jamesbeck.eth It's interesting you had such that a reaction to the Terra Luna collapse. I I felt that was among the many. That one was I don't know, I didn't feel maybe it's because I didn't have any money in Terra Luna. So I didn't I wasn't
Kris I didn't either. That's the scary part.
jamesbeck.eth Right. And it does suck to one day wake up and see half your portfolio wiped out. But I think the FTX drama really affected me because FTX was so part of the mainstream. There were super bullet commercials. There was you know, they had a whole
Kris Yeah. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth cast of all these people they paid to be promoting crypto. And when that collapsed, it confirmed everything that the critics said, which is crypto is all a big, big fat scam. Here's, here's an example, this guy. And that to me was devastating because I I said, Really, you've given so much ammunition, crypto can never come back from it.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth And I thought the reputation could never get worse than that. And then Trump came along. And then Trump coin. And then the fact that he earned a billion dollars in his crypto dealings last year. crypto is this pariah in the United States that, you know. I have a friend at the New York Times that he admitted this to me last week. He's Yeah, occasionally I'd be talking and I'll mention my f I have a friend that works in crypto and they're that's sus. are you sure about that? it's just the reputation is really hard, hard to come back from.
Kris Are we fighting are we fighting a losing battle?
jamesbeck.eth Well, I think the yeah, in some ways, yes, but I think it's really a branding thing. It's if pe you know, I think the twenty twenty-five fork in the road, or really the post-FTX, post-Trump fork in the road, was do you keep building the crypto casino? And some people have, and some people are doing quite well doing that,
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth the Pump Fun side, or do you build sort of the traditional financial technology? And maybe this is a false binary. There's some there's a third way. But if you go to a SIBOS they they know that FTX was a scam. they, they, they saw Bernie Madoff. They know what scams look But they actually don't deny the technology itself. And I think what ends up happening is crypto itself becomes this sort of casino term. It's the same way that prediction markets and online, you know, online betting and sports betting are. And it's okay, that's fine. You can do that. You can do whatever you want with your money. Go gamble it. The financial technology stuff becomes boring. that's what I'm that's
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth where we're trying to get ENS to, where it becomes this critical infrastructure that people don't even think about unless you work in the really arcane, minute details of how JSON packages of financial information transfer across the internet. that's that's where it becomes this standard. and registry standard that is just really it's bookkeeping. You don't really care about it unless you have to
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth do it. And someone creates this standard. And yeah, it seems maybe a little b boring compared to the era of free money, but that era is just really left us, in my opinion. Or it or it exists,
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth but it's in the gambling side.
Kris Yeah. And okay, but can I ask what made you leave Consensus and it was it the opportunity that presented itself from Mirror Guys or was it something else?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, it was a little bit, it was right around post Terra Luna crash, it was summer twenty twenty three. I had met Dennis who started Mirror, and he had a really compelling I was a user of Mirror. I loved the way that they started with the right
Kris Yep.
jamesbeck.eth race. I found all my favorite cr you know, Ethereum adjacent writing was being published on Mirror. And I was always a proponent within the company of consensus, we should always be using our technology. let's not use, let's not publish blogs, let's publish mirror blog posts and publish them as NFTs. And I'm a writer and I just loved the product they had built. And he's we're looking for our first ever marketing hire. And we've gotten to where we have without marketing. Let's see where we can go. And was very much caught up in that vision. sadly though, they were also going through a transition of Not really they would make a dollar per mint. So
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth if someone published an article and a thousand people minted it, you'd make a thousand dollars as the company. but outside of the commemorative NFT meta, do you remember when people did that? Base
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth launched, they launched their blog on Mirror, 200,000 people collected it. Mirror made, you know, a bunch of money from that. But there were only so many of those companies and so many of those moments. So he was already thinking, Dennis was already thinking way more toward Farcaster, what Farcaster was creating, which is, what people do on chain is downstream of what they see on Twitter. So what if there's a social network where you can copy trade and you can see what other people are doing and then make your decisions? That idea is essentially what the FOMO app is. I don't know if you've used FOMO at all, but
Kris Mm-hmm. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth essentially he was let's Let's pivot mirror and sell it to Paragraph and try to create that. to you know, which didn't end up succeeding. There's I think a lot of people had that same idea around the same time.
Kris Yeah. Yeah yeah. But it was the the the acquisition was success, the it was acquired by Putzko Paragraph?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, I Union Square Ventures had invested both in Paragraph and in Mirror and AVC he published on both and he said I think there is room for a w a crypto publishing platform. So he didn't want to see them both die. So he's let's just, you know, tie them both up. And it was considered an acquisition, but it was really a sale of assets because all of people's writing on mirror exists as NFTs in perpetuity, but the sort of front end is now managed under paragraph
Kris So you you were working as a marketing person on the team, right?
jamesbeck.eth I was reading your writing back then that you were publishing. Yeah. We would
Kris and really nice.
jamesbeck.eth we had a a Slack bot show every single article that was published. So I was reading everything. The good, the bad,
Kris Nice.
jamesbeck.eth the schizophrenic. I forget the guy
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth that eventually started publishing as who started Malady. his shit was so s so crazy.
Kris I don't know his name.
jamesbeck.eth yeah. Fong. Charlotte Fong. But yeah,
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth it was there was a lot of good stuff being published on Mirror. And I actually what I liked about Mirror was it also bridged with the NFT artist communities. One of the I think the saddest things that have happened, not even just the easy money DeFi stuff. I thought there was an amazing amount of talented artists that created companies I I really loved all the music platforms Catalog, Nina Protocol. I thought there was a a huge interest of people part of the underground music scene. They're just
Kris Yeah. What happened with those? Sound XYZ?
jamesbeck.eth they're the economics, I think, just didn't work out. but I also feel there's always a when you take VC funding, there's a real pressure to kind of
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth re return the capital within a few years. But some of these ideas don't can't be that successful in three years. You need a full decade of working on it.
Kris Things yeah. I th I feel like the
jamesbeck.eth Nina had this incredible community. everyone loved it. And and it was the first time where my own personal interests in the underground music community were overlapping with Nina, where they were all of a sudden never having used crypto before, publishing music on Nina because, you know, whatever boogeyman of the day, Bandcamp was taking too many fees. Bandcamp ended up reviving its reputation. But Spotify, you know. A lot of these musicians took their
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth music off Spotify because it's extractive and SoundCloud really went into the inchidification of the platform and added way more ads. And it yeah, I think it's just really if you take external investment and don't create a sustainable business, you're under a lot of from pressure pressure from your investors to to not even return in the money, but 10x their return before they say
Kris But what's even scariest, even more scary right now, is that they don't even want NX and they don't want the return on investment within a year or two years or three years. With AI and these companies, man, the growth that investors
jamesbeck.eth Hmm. Yeah.
Kris are expecting is just insane. I
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris have a f I have a friend and I don't know a lot about their business, so I probably shouldn't say much because I'm gonna butcher it. But essentially they ha they work something about with the compute and and graphic cards and they have their proprietary algorithm for 3D modeling in real time, some kind of environments. And they have gigantic I think even US Navy is is one of their clients and they have so many c you know clients in in these areas and gaming and all that stuff. They make a lot of money, but obviously they have huge amount of expenses, kind of expenditures on
jamesbeck.eth From the compute.
Kris on from the compute, right? They've been trying to raise just five million dollars. keep everything afloat and tr and try to scale. But their financial projections, project them at kind of I think, becoming profitable after a year, year and a half, or something that. And it's been th three, four months, they have n zero, zero leads. No investor wants to touch them. Because everyone is trying to make you know, everyone's trying to find the next, you know, lovable or the next whatever, right? I swear to God, my ex sometimes I'm gonna I'm I can become depressed if I just spend too much time on X because I scroll scroll and there's okay, this is you know, last year this time you know, we scale f I don't know, from two million to sixty five million. It just tweets this and it's so annoying. well I know this is not a reality, obviously. There's handful of these companies and I don't know how or why, but investors are only interested in AI these days. So yeah, now it's harder than ever. someone recently said that it's easier than ever, to make something and harder than than ever to make money out of that something. And it's
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, that's that's a that's a good take on the current state of things as a builder.
Kris And I was gonna say on on top of the with regards to music platforms and stuff that, the obviously the economics don't work behind that. maybe they didn't work behind mirror and publishing platforms, maybe don't even work in general for anything on chain. at least not
jamesbeck.eth Mm.
Kris yet. But at this point we're definitely, definitely way too early. Way too early. And you know, again, as they say, being too early is kind of the same as being wrong.
jamesbeck.eth Huh. Yeah.
Kris So right. the we're going through the same thing right now with our product, which is Namera. I don't know if I've told you about it, but it's basically, you know, a gentic platform that lets you put these permissions on top of on chain agents that so
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris you can restrict agents to not do anything outside of their predefined scope, which and everything is enforced on chain. Obviously, that's kind of the ther deterministic approach to putting these permissions And it's
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris very b it's very bulky, right? And there's literally no money moving on chain right now for us. There's no commun there's no platforms that that do this so we can engage with and say hey guys, we have these sets of permission permissions and policies that you can kind of leverage and we have this multimodular plug-in based infrastructure for any smart account that sh that anyone can plug into and use their on-chain agents for anything. When the reality is that most of the use cases are around just devs, you know, fucking around and having fun.
jamesbeck.eth But I'm I'm very interested in the agenda commerce side of things. And I think w you know, we're very early today, but I wouldn't get too down on that because if you look at tempo, you know, they have the backing of every you know, Stripe and Paradigm and you sort they have the early head start of what any developer would dream of for their sort of agenda commerce use case, no one's using it. outside of dev's
Kris Really?
jamesbeck.eth fucking around. Yeah, it's just very few people are actually paying for services, agent to agent payments. it's still so hypothetical.
Kris Is that what is it? MPP machine payments protocol, that one?
jamesbeck.eth Uh-huh. And you know, x402, we're still dealing with
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth twenty nineteen era DeFi transaction volume. so maybe
Kris It can't
jamesbeck.eth it maybe it will increase. And, you know, maybe in the future, even in five years, we'll be obviously the era of someone deciding how to manage a portfolio is so labor intensive and error prone, you would just have your agents. manager portfolio and maybe it's yeah, you're gonna be seeking information that requires payments to an on online journal that provides an API for the agent to download a PDF to find out information. all these
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth use case ideas are there, but I don't really see it happening. Greg, Greg Skrill on our team, love he's I would say very much at the forefront of using AI tools and he'll use it to be Hey, buy me a sandwich. But he
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth used that just to test it and he hasn't done it since. It's easier just to go to a store or go on DoorDash and order a sandwich. do I really
Kris Yeah, yeah.
jamesbeck.eth need to write out order me a sandwich? Or can I use an app that also has been, you know, people are earning three hundred thousand dollars to make sure that the clicks and the pressing of the buttons are gonna l make sure you have that payment go through. Already these apps are very optimized. the world is easy. I I don't know.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth Anyone who's agents are gonna make my world easier for commerce activities, I'm it's already pretty damn smooth. Yeah.
Kris I'm skeptical too. when people when people try to show me shopping agents, I get annoyed. Because my
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, yeah.
Kris girlfriend enjoys just going there and touching stuff.
jamesbeck.eth The act of shopping. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Kris t touch this, touch this. When I go, I just go and I see something and I buy it, right? But
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris she just enjoyed the whole process. And even even on the phone, she just enjoys w watching at things and scrolling through and you know, testing, blah blah. So I'm not super sold on any of these. I we're building these agents on chain, trading on chain, but I'm not convinced that that a billion, multi billion dollar fund is gonna come and says, okay, I'm just gonna delegate this portfolio management to an agent. Maybe for specific stuff, you know, high frequency trading or based on like
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris some real world news, act this way or that way. But
jamesbeck.eth Right. I wish I had an agent saying, keep track of this NVIDIA Jensen Huang situation
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth and if there's any indication that he might step down a CO, sell all your maybe those kind
Kris Exactly.
jamesbeck.eth of use cases, but yeah.
Kris So we're building in the a in that space, but I'm I'm very open minded and and super not super convinced yet. But that kinda d you've kind of sparked something in my head. I have a question there. If tempo is not being used or it they don't have as much adoption as one would as one would hope, wha what is the moat for chains? Is it developers? Is it on chain activity? Is it money flowing in? Is it their reputation and potential partners that they can that they can get? what is it? Is it users? if if Tempo and those guys don't have if Stripe doesn't have users, I don't know who does.
jamesbeck.eth so Tempo has eighty-nine million in total value locked in DeFi. But yeah, it's its chain fees in over the last twenty four hours is fourteen dollars, which might not mean much because the fees are pretty low. Two hundred sixty one thousand DEX volume, six thousand this is what I was looking for, six thousand active addresses. And so largely those are probably agents. But like
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth six thousand addresses, that's n that's That's a toy at this it's still like
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth people testing. so their moat is that they have a lot of money. And I guess when the money runs out, or they or maybe it's the use case hasn't we haven't had enough time for people for everyday users to be yeah, I do want to pay for things via my agents. I think there's there's also the adoption curve, very few people are using agents. And it's interesting to see now that you have Muse and Grokbot, big web two companies that have created agents, will it become more consumer friendly? But I'm also not convin at least I I can't speak about what the public opinions are in Serbia, but public opinions in the US around AI are very it's AI and crypto are pretty maligned things. I think there's a few reasons. The messaging from AI companies has been horrid. who wants to hear someone say, we're creating super intelligence, machine intelligence that we don't know if we can control, that may take everyone's jobs, and also is creating data centers that burn, you know, Grok, their data centers are outside of Memphis and people are getting cancer and asthma because they're they're there is such a rush to build these data centers that they're burning natural gas. They're not even solar punk future yeah, we're using windmills and hydroelectric dams. It's no, they're straight up burning
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth gas into the air to run Grokbot. It's I feel horrible using Grok because I just know it's running on these servers outside of Memphis and poor people, mostly black people, are the ones suffering from it. It's the public opinion around data centers and AI in general is pretty negative. Now, I say that And I know also people might feel that way, but when they Google something and they're getting Gemini responses, they might start talking to Gemini. Tons of young people use ChatGPT for everything. So it could be a temporary public opinion thing, but the actual usage of it is going to be increasing. And then eventually it will get to a point where everyone is comfortable paying for things on chain and you know, giving money to an agent. I have no idea. I'd love to see Muse statistics Muse is showing up everywhere. I d you use WhatsApp, right? I'm I see the little Muse character in WhatsApp now. They're really pushing it. So maybe people are using Muse. I don't know.
Kris I never saw anything of muse. I use WhatsApp daily as well. Maybe it's not rolled out in Serbia yet.
jamesbeck.eth Maybe, yeah. There's a little tiny muse character in the bottom. To I don't know what it's doing there, but I guess to try to get you to use it.
Kris Yeah. Do you know who's Tristan Harris?
jamesbeck.eth No.
Kris He's the super cool guy, Tristan Harris. I'll send you I'll just send you the name.
jamesbeck.eth he American technology ethicist.
Kris When you hear him speak, this is what one of the reasons why I enjoy talking to you as well. You're very you're very easy to talk to, first of all, and then the way you express yourself is very kind of fluent. You have a very kind of coherent stream thoughts and you convert them into language very nicely, unlike me. But my language second second language English.
jamesbeck.eth You're you're speaking in a a second language, yeah, yeah.
Kris Yeah, yeah. So so he's Very, very, very eloquent and he speaks very, very interestingly about AI. everything he says is very rooted in in some facts. He was the guy who kind of early blew the alarm on social media. He created the social dilemma, which is the super popular documentary way back when on
jamesbeck.eth I did see that. Yeah.
Kris around Brexit, and now he's kind of you know blowing the whistle on on AI and how all of these tech giants are rushing. basically to to this general super intelligence or call it whatever you want. He's just a super, super cool guy and very, very interesting to to follow. He recently created he was one of the persons who created this documentary called AI Doc. maybe you saw it, maybe not.
jamesbeck.eth I had heard about it, I haven't seen it yet.
Kris it's it's alright. but if you just follow Tristan on Instagram or somewhere, I'm sure you'll absolutely enjoy what he's what he what he talks about. yeah, but back to on chain stuff and AI and all of this and just the adoption and everything. You know, my thesis is that blockchains are kind of inevitable. I think stable
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris coins are inevitable. I think also C B D Cs are gonna rise. I know there's jurisdictions and governments right now who are planning this. So
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris it's it's it's gonna become inevitable. And I think we're gonna have rules and restrictions. There's gonna be very synonymous to borders and stuff, okay, we have a nationwide blockchain stable you know, currency or whatever, and you ha you can use it and act with it and do this, but only if and then we're starting meddling with rules and regulations and stuff
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris that. So it's gonna be that. But for the most part, I see it as a transitioning period. I think I asked you, does Ethereum need institutions and and and stuff that? And I think you cannot really kind of and this is the same kind of thing for does does ENS need DNS, right? You know, how about
jamesbeck.eth Mm, mm-hmm.
Kris handshake domains? just fuck everything, let's start you
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris know from scratch. I'm not a proponent of that. I think the transition needs to happen gradually over years and years and years, maybe even decades. And then there should be a tipping point at some point. And then we say, okay, how do we least painfully, graduate from a traditional rails to a better ones? But there's gonna
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris be huge, probably thirty, forty years of both Rails working, both on-chain and traditional, kind of for finances,
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris for banking, for anything, whether that's for domains, for for finances, for payments, for whatever. So that's my take. I think we have just started the transition and we'll see how things play out. What do you think?
jamesbeck.eth Well, with ENS, you know, someone asked me at DevCon what my thought is about Docway. And I honestly, maybe this is controversial and you know, I I'm actually all for it. I think having other people experiment with different rules around creating a namespace is totally fine. There's there's but there's a different goal. So if if the goal of Docway is you know There is a risk and the ENS DAO is captured by labs and we need a different namespace that has different rules, that's fine. But then if you're claiming that, an alternate namespace dot SNS or dot, you're saying handshake,
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth you end up having the problem where the whole point of having a rule set, maybe the institution of ICANN, is so that we can all you can get people from all over the world to agree. on a standard. And so
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth standards are actually safer because what it means is if my docway resolves in the Ethereum context to something and your Dockway resolves differently, and then I'm using an app that doesn't know which one is which, that's actually not a good system because you could be sending it to
Kris Yeah. Yep.
jamesbeck.eth the wrong address. And it's always it's the same reason why, you know, in its conception, ENS worked with the DNS root. Because it's saying we don't want to create an alternate namespace dot bot or dot
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth dot agent. you know, we could have gone the unstoppable domains way and say,
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth we'll just create a dot ape, dot agent, whatever. And then all of a sudden, this GTLD round that just happened, now there are these new owners of these TLDs. And you're essentially saying we're gonna create a duplicate namespace, and that creates name collisions.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth And so I think the whole point of a standard is that you don't have it's just for s what's the word I'm looking for? It's the same instinct that people have when they named species. You or creating a t periodic table of elements, any sort of taxonomy, the whole point of the human endeavor of creating order where there is no order. is to disambiguate or create non-duplications of the something so that if I point to that tree, I can say, this is known to be this species. And if it's not, maybe it's an evolution, we'll call it this thing. But I you
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth can't have two people pointing to the same thing and saying, This is A, and someone else says, no, this is B. humans have always been trying to disambiguate and create order. And that's why we have encyclopedias and registries and phone numbers. The whole point of a phone number and is to just say, This is that person, and I know I'm guaranteed to call someone and get that answer.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth And so, I I love the whole idea of rip it down, create something new. But if it's not working within the larger order of things, it's not as useful. And I think the whole point of a naming system is supposed to be for as maximum utility and usefulness. And
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth I I don't know, maybe that's a very boring opinion, but
Kris And I I don't think it's a I don't think it's a good way for technology to be adopted. I d I don't
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris I genuinely don you have a reliable system that's have been that's been working for what thirty, forty, fifty years and you just wanna
jamesbeck.eth Right, right.
Kris yeah, it's it's just bad. But we've jumped into the ENS conversation straight to the one of the biggest problems. I'm
jamesbeck.eth Hmm. Yeah. Yeah.
Kris I'm more curious, let's start at the beginning. How did you hear about DNS and then who brought you to how did you how did you land the job?
jamesbeck.eth Well, so I started writing about ENS back at Consensus and in part
Kris okay.
jamesbeck.eth there wasn't a lot of things you could do on chain. You know, there were DeFi
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth prot a few DeFi protocols. but if I was talking to someone who is a marketer who's Yeah, I don't really I don't know what token to swap into, so I have no reason to use an AMM, then I would say, Well, here's the first thing you should do download MetaMask and buy a name. And they're What's a name for? I said, if you remember your zero X address, you're a genius because you know those 42 characters by heart. Most people won't. It's DNS for blockchains. so I've been explaining ENS since really it launched and why someone should get it and what to do with it. And it's
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth also fun because it would be you go to this website and you connect your wallet and you do this thing, you're you're using Ethereum. You're now. on-chain. so I'd always, you know, known about ENS. I didn't really know about who was behind it and how it, you know, how the DAO worked or which company which companies interacted in the Dow. and then around 2024, Iskander approached me when I was at DevCon and he said, Hey, we're hiring ahead of growth. So that's kind of how it came about. you know, I was I then did a lot more research on name chain at the time and what V2 was going to be. And really also was curious about just generally I think ENS is interesting in that it it also invites a different type of investor class of domainers. And I knew very little about I knew about ICANN, but I didn't know about the whole industry of domainers and how yeah, just generally how people view and value these
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth assets. I yeah, I think that my goal for ES I think my understanding around what's possible with naming has expanded. I think much more in the idea of what a registry is and how useful registries are in business contexts, in financial contexts, and how much the you know, how much should you you can say something as simple as chain IDs, that's being stored in someone's GitHub. those should be on chain. That's now
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth possible. But when we think about financial assets coming on chain, specifically equities and money market funds, everyone's using their own, some are using ERC 3643, but there's different standards and we're all kind of we're still in the discovery exploratory phase of how should things be standardized and named. And anything
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth that needs a name. And a standard to me is ENS's domain. No pun intended.
Kris Yeah, what's what's really yeah, you know what's really interesting to me, because I've I've been with TNS for three plus years now. And you know what's the coolest thing? So it started as a simple domain naming protocol, right? So
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris hey, decentralized domains, the censorship you know resistance websites, that's it. We're Ethereum name service, right? Domain name service. and from there, people started using it as hey Get your wallet username, wallet profile. And then we started calling them profiles, passports, usernames,
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. Identities, yeah.
Kris identity. And then it it starts we started in kind of throwing in this word identity, right? And then we started asking questions, well, what is an identity? and then subnames kind of came along and people were you know, base, CB.ID did 15 million back in the day, Uniswap. So subnames kind of took off. And now we're at the verge of this new trend, and it's already started because there's already a few standards there, that where ENS is being used for agent identity. We have we have it being used for privacy with fluid key, curvy, and all these apps that kind of ENS is kind of the central point without which it's a it's a it's a core piece of the technology in their stack without which you cannot actually do stealth not stealth addresses, but privacy.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris privacy, you know, transactions. So there's so it evolved into so many cool things. And what you guys have have done with I think it's called you you pronounce it GLEIF, which is the basically the kind of the IDs
jamesbeck.eth Global Global Legal Identifier Foundation. Yeah.
Kris Yeah, so there are just so many aspects where ENS can go. And we haven't even touched I think the something that is really cool that I I myself don't understand quite well yet, which is how does ENS work with RWAs? And this is something I think you wrote about, but I I I don't remember reading it and I don't quite get it. So can we talk about that for a for a second?
jamesbeck.eth So it's kind of it's inherent in this glyph thing, but I think of ENS as a container. the NFT can have this metadata associated with it. So it's the name can point to different sources of information. It may not need to confirm if that information is valid, or it may need to. And so with the glyph example, there was a lot of effort in figuring out how could A resolver check the information that someone has put in there to say, I am ACME Business Corp. And here I have Acme.eth, and here is my official identification number that now all companies use post 2008 financial crisis. a little bit of the history of how Glyph came about is that after the financial crisis happened and people were trying to figure out where this big unwind led and which companies were affected. They realized that not everyone had the same ID numbers and that there was different systems and they were conflicting information. It was a big mess.
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth So it came about as there should just every company should have an LEI, a legal identifier. And, when you incorporate a company, you get this LEI. And interestingly, if you're going on chain as a company, you have there's some some indications where it's The block explorer will name and they'll that's Binance's wallet. But generally you're pseudonymous when you're on chain. But what if you're a company that's or a government and you want to just say, I am, this is my address. This is my public address. This is the government of Turkey's public address, or this is JP Morgan, the company. This is our exact fund. You can't really do that. But with ENS, you can. And that's why that glyph integration is exciting. And that relates to the real world asset stuff. right now, everyone is trying to tokenize assets. there's a lot of reasons to do it. 24-7 settlement. It's the same reason why what we think in our agreement for why blockchains win. But the difference is that there's all these competing standards on multiple chains. So Ondo Finance will issue, you know, tokenized NVIDIA stock. Coinbase will issue tokenize NVIDIA stock on base network. Binance will issue tokenized NVIDIA stock on Binance. all of a sudden you now have and you you maybe just live let's say you live in Nigeria and you're on an app and you're How do I get this stock? 'Cause I want I don't have access. I'm gonna I think I froze, so I'm gonna try to.
Kris Yeah, yeah, you're good.
jamesbeck.eth And I think one of the ways in which ENS could help is by creating a sort of tokenized asset registry or RWA registry
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth so that you know this is the official ondo stock or this is the official Binance stock. And the challenge right now is that not only aren't they multiple chains, but some tokenized stocks. doesn't even give you the same rights as the real stock, redemption rights or shareholder rights.
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth And so there's a real there's a whole there's let's say just say many flavors of tokenized stock. And I think currently the way in which stocks are given tickers or, you know, that tickers become kind of the standard. And There's a lot of ways in which you could do that with ENS, except maybe it's someone imports their DNS and then issues all of the RWAs, and then you can see it's Nvidia.ondo.finance, and you know
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth this is the actual token that I'm supposed to be getting. but I think the other thing is this is still maybe I love your advice on this. we at ENS Labs have different opinions on how to make this possible. And I think where we're leading to is that instead of letting every tokenized stock issuer create their own registry, we should create a one large registry that starts out with a few partners, maybe it's ondo Securities, a few of these partners, and make them all use the same standard and have the same information as associated metadata. And then from there It becomes undeniable that any other new enter, anyone new entering the space, all uses that as the standard. Meaning it's ENS becomes enshrined as the way to name a stock as it's coming on chain. So it's
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth step one is someone's gonna help you issue the token. Step two, name that token and make sure it conforms to the ENS tokenized stock registry. Right. So I
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth think that's kind of the ma the master plan for there.
Kris Question, did you get a chance to look into the token name service? I think we spoke probably a few weeks about this, possibly more. Time flies, I don't even know. But the token name service was essentially started with the same kind of idea to have.
jamesbeck.eth The one that was built on Yeah, the one that was built on Solana, right?
Kris No no no no no. It's TK let me send it here in the chat. here it is. So it's TKn.eth.limo.
jamesbeck.eth right, yes.
Kris I shared this with you I I don't remember when it was probably a few weeks ago. So these were the guys who essentially wanted to create CoinGecko on chain, right?
jamesbeck.eth I
Kris And anyone can contribute and at least their token, their contracts, and everything about them, and they would assign them TKN dot eth subdomain, I think. That's how it worked. So it's a very similar idea.
jamesbeck.eth Do you do you know the team behind them? Or behind this?
Kris yeah yeah yeah I know a guy who used to work on this. I can probably try to dig him dig him up in my inbox in Telegram and I can send you his
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, I'd love to Because this is, yeah, the same idea is there's some sort of master registry that anyone can then fetch the metadata on that token. I think the hard part though is getting everyone to agree on using it.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth We're even having the debate of does it is it a dot ETH? Because if you're if you're Fidelity and you're issuing a ton of funds and they're gonna be on six blockchains, Ethereum is always number one and it may have the most volume, but you're also issuing on Solana, Canton, Stellar.
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth sh is
Kris Look.
jamesbeck.eth there a neutral, you know?
Kris Yeah, that's that's honestly my probably hot take about ENS. And I gotta say I've had more success in communicating to fintechs and neobanks, that they can use any domain that they want or they already own.
jamesbeck.eth Right.
Kris So it's not an additional kind of overhead for them to I have to do this, I have to do that, I have to register something on chain. No, nothing. The domains that you own,
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris sometimes I'll even ask Hey, how many domains do you have of if of your, you know, of your business?
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris And so it's kind of start conversation there. but yeah, I agree. using dot ID dot me and probably right now when the that it probably won't happen for another year or so, all the new strings to be delegated. but after they do get delegated, we're gonna have dot crypto.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. I guess they're saying by twenty twenty eight, I think, or something. Maybe
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth even a little bit after. Yeah. Yeah, you're right. You're gonna have
Kris Yeah, so so I
jamesbeck.eth other options.
Kris I I think ENS as a protocol should have more neutral stance. I I understand that dot eth is obviously the revenue generating mechanism and obviously it's gonna be the the OG kind of the dot com of the web two.
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris but at the same time, I definitely see a lot of value in communicating that we are so much more t today I had a call with with one neobank when I spoke about this.
jamesbeck.eth yeah?
Kris Yeah, yeah, yeah.
jamesbeck.eth And how many domains did they have when you asked them? I'm curious.
Kris I didn't ask these guys, I didn't ask them. The my team l led the call. I only jumped in here and there. but it was
jamesbeck.eth I'm curious 'cause sometimes I talk to companies and they have a dozen domains for defensive purposes or
Kris yeah yeah most of them do, but these guys I didn't ask them. it was this was the the contact from I don't even know. We go to so many events that I I can't keep them straight
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris in my head. But it was one of the events that Happy went to and was the contact
jamesbeck.eth cool.
Kris from there. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So we're kind of following up from there and now probably next few weeks we're gonna follow up from people from Devcon. but yeah. that that's kind of my hot take. I so I I wanted to ask you so w you obviously know we're service providers and I'm sorry I if you have to go or something just let me know if this is
jamesbeck.eth I d I have I have ten more minutes and then I have to get ready for this next meeting.
Kris man. Sorry. I I wish I knew that because I wish we had more time to talk. But anyway, we are service providers, right? and we measure our success in a few things, how many products
jamesbeck.eth Mm-hmm.
Kris we we put out there, what are the success of those each products individually, for example for Resolve O we s look at how many resolutions we handle, process and all that stuff. For the NS components, we might look at something else. For namespace in general, we look at the number of sub namames issued and resolutions handled, and all that stuff. But I'm curious, how do you measure maybe relative to your position or more on the company level, how do you measure
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris the t the indicators of the success that you guys as labs and you individually
jamesbeck.eth first metric has to be registrations and renewals.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth that's the health of the DAO, which is the health of this whole endeavor of all of us working and trying to build and support ENS. with V2, it interestingly, because I think this is part of Nick's idea of when you create something, you don't want to worsen. the thing that you created if there's a new version. So he's always been very adamant from the start that if you have a name on V1, you'll never have to upgrade it or migrate it to V2. you can always keep it on V one.
Kris Yeah. Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth but I wanted to also, you know, for our team, we're trying to get people to upgrade to V two because we do think there's a lot more you can do if you're building a project or a business around subnames. You just you know, so
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth a metric is How many names have upgraded to V2? as of today, it is twenty eight, twenty-nine thousand.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth so not, you know, it's a a small percent of where we want to get to, but that's a big metric. And then at the end of the day, we also need to think about other revenue sources. I don't think anyone has ever thought, or maybe there have been conversations in the Dow, but the protocol can survive off of registrations and renewals, but that puts you in maintenance mode.
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth you could just have a lean group of people that are just maintaining the protocol and only hobbyists and small user groups use it. But we also need to think about, right now it's free public infra to be a Uniswap or a base and build a whole subname project around. maybe the RWA idea I'm talking about, there's a consortium model and it runs more a Linux where people pay in to keep the common infra running. the Linux decentralized decentralized trust. I'm hope I'm not butchering that. That acronym that basically runs BESU, which is the technology stack that Consensus originally built, and then they gave it to Linux Foundation. Under what used to be called Hyperledger and now it's just called the Linux Decentralized Trust or whatever. But the whole I the whole model for that is a lot of people are going to rely on the shared infrastructure, whether it's a big bank or Swift. And so they all pay dues to keep it running. So there's other metrics around the financial health of the Down the ecosystem that may, you know, we may have to start thinking beyond simply. registrations and renewals. one
Kris All right.
jamesbeck.eth last thing is obviously we want a lot of people to know about ENS so we also keep track of views and all those metrics and website visits and how many people people's sentiment, you know, there was a lot of positive sentiment and there was some real critical feedback around the V2 launch and the current state of the apps, which I to think that they're still kind of beta because all the things we want to include in them couldn't we had to launch the protocol in my opinion before the apps were in their perfect state,
Kris Yeah. Yeah. Man, ENS has matured into so many different things and I think
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris it's gonna keep growing and it's gonna keep kind of solidifying its position within all of these verticals, and it's so cool and it's kind of an honor to be part of that also. yeah, so many cool things. Before I let you go, do you wanna do some rapid fire stuff? Because I have some really cool questions in here because
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, sure. Yeah, yeah.
Kris my AI agents did a very good job. Okay, so we didn't spend too much time on ENS V two. So what are the coolest things about ENSv2 in your opinion?
jamesbeck.eth Every name gets its own registry. I think that
Kris Catcha.
jamesbeck.eth we're gonna have to explore that further, but yeah.
Kris So ENSV2 brings new possibilities for sub names with permissions, custom namespaces. Which apps and use cases do you are you find the most exciting? And do you think the builders will find the most exciting to experiment with?
jamesbeck.eth Creating a registry is kind of boring work, but important work. Whether that registry is every user you have or a registry of natural objects and you're keeping track of it. With V2, if you need to update something, you can do it all on you can update all the names at once. You can also give subnames sort of the permission so that they can actually be kind of separate from the parent and really feel they own the subname. And create their own registry.
Kris With ENSv2 is now live officially, what's the biggest remaining obstacle to mainstream adoption of ENS?
jamesbeck.eth We gotta get the apps in a place that accepts someone without a wallet and maybe even no crypto. And that's coming. So
Kris Hell yeah.
jamesbeck.eth being able to buy any s name with no crypto and no wallet even prior.
Kris I would also say correct resolution, because i
jamesbeck.eth Correct resolution.
Kris if ENS names, whether they are imported DNS names or .eth domains, if they serve as containers for th hundred blockchains,
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris all wallets must implement resolution correctly. So each time the name is typed in and you wanna send Bitcoin, it resolves the Bitcoin address. You wanna send money on USDC on Polygon, it correctly resolves it. So that's I think in my opinion the big one. okay. what would make you say a year from now that ENS V two was a genuine success?
jamesbeck.eth if everyone
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth if the ninety-seven apps that we're tracking that integrated ENS have a full complete integration, similar to what you're saying, there's a varying degree of integration of ENS. Some people just do forward and reverse resolution. Some people some companies support DNS resolution. What made ENS V2 so hard and was One, regaining connection with all these companies and people have left and teams have changed. And two, getting them all to upgrade to the Universal Resolver. And that's the first step in getting the complete ENS integration. And we wanna just improve that ever more.
Kris Right. Okay, ENS has grown enormously. We all know that. many wallets, exchanges, communities, and partnerships and apps, everything that you've guys done. What's been the biggest d driver of growth so far?
jamesbeck.eth the biggest driver of growth is gonna have to be okay, this is actually kind of ironic, but the amount of attempts that people people make to steal money, we're always in a very adversarial environment in crypto. But address poisoning is Used to be a small thing, but now with the advent of AI, it's really easy
Kris Mm.
jamesbeck.eth to do a little dusting and try to confuse people about their, where they last sent money. And I think honestly, any business that's a a fintech neobank, they get the idea that no one wants a zero X address, but they need a financial reason to prioritize integrating
Kris Yes.
jamesbeck.eth ENS. And oftentimes that financial reason is increasingly how many attempts there are daily at address poisoning. So ironically, people trying to scam people and steal money helps strengthen the argument for ENS as a necessary tool to save your users money.
Kris Yeah. In my experience people only when I say people, I mean companies that we approach usually care about how does this help us grow our user base? Number two,
jamesbeck.eth Right.
Kris how does this help us grow our revenue? Nothing else. If it doesn't fall into either of those two, so
jamesbeck.eth That's if it doesn't fall into those, doesn't matter.
Kris it's it's really difficult to communicate the value of ENS sometimes. But over
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris the years we've kinda I we've honed it we've hone it in.
jamesbeck.eth Yeah. Yeah.
Kris d that maybe is a good kind of setup for the next question. Wha what is the hardest thing about growing an open protocol such as ENS.
jamesbeck.eth I think the fact that every app, every wallet is trying to be chain agnostic and
Kris Mm-hmm.
jamesbeck.eth the .eth itself is so associated with only ENS or with only Ethereum that people don't realize that there's all these coin types you can add to your .eth name that you can i even import a DNS. So I think it's been hard, you know, it's our branding points to Ethereum, but there's actually other things you can do with ENS and so I think that's always been a challenge.
Kris Right. And one last thing, you said in one of your interviews, the more useful ENS is, the more it becomes the standard identity infrastructure. So my question is how do we make this happen? How do we make ENS undeniable we did for Ethereum?
jamesbeck.eth Expect a lot of ENSIPs in the coming months. I think the more e the more coin types, the more or you know, cleaning up our coin types so that it's actually reflective of the chains that are actually transacting the most. new types of text record fields or fields that support things GLEIF it's the container, the the sort of fields in the container grow and and are a bit more specific. even with ENSIP-25 and 26 that allowed for agent identity. And I think that's as ENS is growing, it's gonna have more ENS IPs and we're gonna have a much more dedicated team now that V2 is live, focused only on new use cases and improving that.
Kris Man, thank you so much. This has been so fun. we didn't even
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris have the time to talk about AI. Didn't even have time to talk about the events. We didn't have the time to talk about any of these things, and yet it was a blast, my friend. We should do it.
jamesbeck.eth We should do this once a quarter, yeah. Or every couple of months.
Kris We should do every time we submit a quarterly report, we d
jamesbeck.eth Yeah, yeah.
Kris we we come on and we we talk and have fun. So sorry to
jamesbeck.eth I know, we didn't even get to talk about Jens Jensen Huang and Chinese spies and there's so much to talk about.
Kris Yeah man. You know, I've I've since I've started this and I'm obviously very inexperienced, but it's really hard to balance things. I can obviously just have fun and kind of keep talking about what how we started, you know. but it's so hard to balance things to make this should I make this fun? Should I make this useful for people to should we educate people? Should you know what I mean? So it's it's kind of the art juggling the conversation.
jamesbeck.eth We had a yeah, we had we touched a lot of things. There was, there was some
Kris Yeah. But
jamesbeck.eth greater feelings of anxiety about the market and where it's gone and reflecting on the early eras crypto, but then also we got to talk about V two a little bit and ENS and
Kris Yeah.
jamesbeck.eth yeah.
Kris Hopefully when I as I keep going and I keep getting better at this, things are gonna be more smooth. I feel I should bring people to talk about just one thing. Just let's talk
jamesbeck.eth Yeah.
Kris about ENS in the context of DNS and ICANN. We can spend an hour there and we're good.
jamesbeck.eth Totally. Yeah, I guess we spent an hour and a half on all these topics and I felt even then I would have wanted to go deeper on some of them. But till the next time. Of course.
Kris Yeah, yeah. Yeah. But thanks, man. I really appreciate it. I hope we hope we do this, you know, every every other month, maybe once or twice a year at least. But yeah. Thanks so much and thanks everyone
jamesbeck.eth Let's do that. All right. Always good chatting.
Kris for tuning in.
jamesbeck.eth Cheers. Bye.
Kris Bye guys. Bye.